Chocolate Chip Mandalas (aka cookies)

September 9, 2014

As many of you know, I have fine-tuned my recipe over the years until I have reached what I consider the perfect chocolate chip cookie.  But my obsession doesn’t even come close to this person.  Read and fine-tune to get your perfect version of chocolate chip cookies:

And in case you want my recipe, here it is.  Pay close attention to the process – it really makes a difference.


9/20/11: I just tried something new with my chocolate chip cookie recipe and it turned out so amazing I have to record it. The background of this is that I was at Shakespeare in the Park this summer, and overheard a woman behind me talking about how she had baked her chocolate chip cookies for their picnic. I was so amazed at what I heard, I had to turn around and talk to her, and eventually she offered me a cookie to taste what she was talking about. They were AMAZING!  It boils down to two simple tips:

Tip #1: BROWN the butter before you mix the dough. Just melt it in a sauce pan and keep stirring it until it starts to turn brown. This takes about 5-6 minutes. Be sure to cool it before you add the eggs, so they don’t cook in the heat of the butter. I used salted butter.

Tip #2: Instead of 1 tsp. of regular salt mixed with the flour, toss in a teaspoon of coarse sea salt when you mix in the chocolate chips and nuts. If you wish, sprinkle a few grains on top of each cookie before baking.

The cookies gain a toffee-like richness, and the counterpoint of the pops of salt against the chocolate are divine.  I remember the woman saying that she had gotten the recipe from The Barefoot Contessa. I’ve looked in some of her cookbooks but haven’t found it — at least not yet.


Preheat the oven to 375 F.

2 sticks butter (1 cup), melted but not hot (to brown it, see Tip #1 above)
1 cup brown sugar, packed
1/2 cup white sugar
1 large egg
1 tsp. vanilla

Mix these ingredients together with a spoon, NOT a mixer — you don’t want air in this dough.

Mix together (don’t sift):

1 cup all-purpose flour (I prefer unbleached) plus*
1-1/4 to 1-1/2 cups ground oatmeal (you can grind it in the blender; be sure to press it down in the measuring cup so it’s not fluffy)
1 tsp baking soda
1 tsp salt (If you are using coarse sea salt wait and mix it in with the chocolate chips and nuts in the next step — see Tip #2 above.)

* (Or, just use 2-1/4 cups all-purpose flour)

Stir the dry ingredients into the wet ingredients.  (You might want to start with the lesser amount of oatmeal flour, and add more if needed.) The dough should NOT be shiny or runny; it will be soft but firm enough to hold its shape.  If you have to add a bit of flour, add it one spoonful at a time, stirring after each spoonful, until the dough is no longer shiny.

Stir in:

1 12-oz. package chocolate chips (or better, half chocolate chips and half larger chunks of chocolate) (you can use milk or semi-sweet, your preference)
At least 1/2 cup of nuts (walnuts, pecans or hazelnuts), more if you love nuts
Sea salt (see above)

Now, the perfection is in the baking. First make a test cookie:

Drop a spoonful of dough (about 1-1/4″ in diameter) in the center of a baking sheet.

Put it in the freezer for about 5 minutes, just until the surface of the dough is firm.

Remove from freezer to oven and bake for 8 to 8-1/2 minutes. (You preheated the oven to 375 F, right?)

At this point, the top should not be shiny (no raw dough in the center) and the edges and high points over the nuts are just turning golden. If the center is still gooey, bake for 30 seconds to 1 minute longer. The edge of the cookie should curve around and under, like a “D” and the top should be flat. Freezing the dough helps make this happen — it slows the melting of the dough and helps avoid dreaded “Overcooked Edge Syndrome” which occurs when the edge melts flat onto the cookie sheet and overcooks. If OSE happens, put a couple more tablespoons of flour into the uncooked dough and make another test. Also, be aware that the consistency of the cookie will be different if you don’t put nuts in it, so if you don’t use nuts you may need to add even a bit more flour to make up for the architectural support that nuts provide.

When you remove the cookie sheet from the oven, let it sit with the cookies on it for a couple of minutes (preferably on top of the stove, where the heat from the oven will keep the cookie sheet warm a little longer) so that the heat of the cookie sheet cooks the bottom of the cookie just a bit longer and makes it slightly crispy, while the top stays chewy. This is important: don’t leave the cookies in the oven longer because this will cook the whole cookie, and you will lose the gooey chewiness that makes these cookies so good. When you can touch the cookie sheet, remove the cookies to a rack or paper towels for cooling. One last tip: cool the cookie sheet completely before putting dough on it again, so it doesn’t melt the raw dough you’re about to put on it.  I usually run cold water over the back of it for a second or two to cool it.

Once you have your dough consistency and timing right, the rest of the baking is easy: drop the dough by spoonfuls onto cookie sheets, and freeze each sheetful of cookies while the previous batch bakes.

The result is a perfectly creamy, chewy chocolate chip cookie, with a slightly crisp bottom that helps hold that chewy cookie together long enough to get it from cookie sheet to serving plate to mouth, where it then melts like nirvana.

This may sound like more trouble than it really is, but it’s easy when you get into the rhythm of load cookie sheets – put in freezer – bake – cool and it is worth the little extra effort. These cookies are dense, chewy and slightly crispy on the bottom. They don’t really soak up milk if dunked (no air in the dough, no pockets for milk), but served with cold milk “chasers” there’s perhaps nothing better on earth. (Okay, so I’m a total chocolate chip cookie junky…………)


One Response to “Chocolate Chip Mandalas (aka cookies)”

  1. michele Says:

    I saw something similar on The Pioneer woman’s blog.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: